Views: 1,721 | Downloads: 40 | Responses: 0

Original ArticleOpen Access

Accuracy of Three Methods Used for Thai Children’s Body Weight Estimation

Trakulsrichai S , Boonsri C , Chatchaipun P , Chunharas A

Abstract | Full Text | References | Citation| Response

Close  
Citation

Trakulsrichai S, Boonsri C, Chatchaipun P, Chunharas A. Accuracy of Three Methods Used for Thai Children’s Body Weight Estimation. J Med Assoc Thai 2012;95:1194.

Background:Accurate children’s weight estimation is necessary and important for emergency pediatric care, particularly for drug dosages, electrical therapy, or equipment sizes. Children’s weight is difficult to measure in critically ill patients. Several methods were developed to estimate children’s accurate weight. Most methods were developed from western countries. The methods used currently might not work with Thai children.

Objective: To determine the accuracy of the Broselow tape, family member estimation and the 50th percentile of national weight for height correlation graph for Thai children’s weight estimation.

Material and Method: The authors carried out a prospective study. Children from neonate to 12 years old who presented to the emergency department and general outpatient pediatric clinic were included. The patients were studied in both overall and subgroup analysis (less than 10 kg, 10 to 25 kg, 25 to 40 kg, and over 40 kg). The primary outcome was the accuracy within 10% error of the measured weight and the mean difference of the weight.

Results: Five hundred ninety five patients were included in the present study. There were 333 (55.97%) boys and 262 (44.03%) girls. Family member estimation was the most accurate method with the accuracy within 10% error 85.21% and had the lowest mean difference (-0.262 kg). Family members could estimate weight accurately for all weight subgroups. The Broselow tape was the second most accurate method with the accuracy within 10% error 56.13% and the low mean difference (-0.485 kg). The accuracy within 10% error of the 50th percentile of national weight for height correlation graph was 51.43% and the mean difference was -0.648 kg. Every method had the best estimation in the weight subgroup 10 to 25 kg except the Broselow tape.

Conclusion: Family member estimation was the most accurate method in the present study. The family member could estimate the children’s weight within 10% error of the measured weight about 85% of cases. In case where family member estimation was not available, the Broselow tape was the next accurate alternative method.

Keywords: Thai children’s weight estimation, The Broselow tape, The family member estimation, The 50th percentile of national weight-height correlation graph

Close  
Response

Responses are electronic letters to the editor. They enable our users to debate issues raised in articles published on the jmatonline.com. Although a selection of responses will be included online and in print as readers' letters, their first appearance online means that they are published articles.

Download: PDF